Volleyball
| Player of the Year |
Libero of the Year |
Coach of the Year | Newcomer of the Year | |
| 2011 | Katie Sumner, WIT | Christina Gilene, WIT | Paco Pabrador, WIT | Meghan Vodopich, WIT |
| 2010 | Shaina Bryan, HIR | Kelley Johnson, WOO | Paco Labrador, WIT | Ana Maricic, KEN |
| 2009 | KateLynn Riley, WOO | Holly Leonard, DEN | Ellen Dempsey, HIR | Meg Weissenberger, OWU |
| 2008 | Jackie Williams, WIT | Ali Drushal, WOO | Sarah Davis, WOO | Lizzi Beal, WOO |
| 2007 | Jackie Williams, WIT | Ali Drushal, WOO | Paco Labrador, WIT | Kim Sage, HIR |
| 2006 | Michelle Kozempa, HIR | Ali Drushal, WOO | Cynthia Holliday, OWU | Erin Slattery, WIT |
| Paco Labrador, WIT | ||||
| 2005 | Shana Toth, HIR | Caitlin Krupka, DEN | Ellen Dempsey, HIR | Jackie Williams, WIT |
| 2004 | Sarah Yuskewich, WIT | Emilie Schmid, WIT | Terri Mason, WOO | Megan Taylor, HIR |
| 2003 | Sarah Yuskewich, WIT | Emilie Schmid, WIT | Ellen Dempsey, HIR | Jennifer Hlebovy, HIR |
| 2002 | Sarah Yuskewich, WIT | Connie Surowicz, WIT | Katie Quinter, DEN | |
| 2001 | Tiffany Keller, WIT | Ellen Dempsey, HIR | Monica McDonald, WIT | |
| 2000 | Shelli Habbegger, WIT | Connie Surowicz, WIT | Vicki Kajder, ALL | |
| 1999 | Brittany Baume, WIT | Connie Surowicz, WIT | Brittany Baume, WIT | |
| 1998 | Dawn Reinhardt, WIT | Karen Chambers, CWRU | ||
| 1997 | Beth Nowicki, WIT | Karen Chambers, CWRU | ||
| Kim Woodring, WIT | ||||
| 1996 | Carrie Kraly, OWU | Cynthia Holliday, OWU | ||
| 1995 | Kim Woodring, WIT | Connie Surowicz, WIT | ||
| 1994 | Sheila Gisbrecht, OWU | Linda Bush, WOO | ||
| Cynthia Holliday, OWU | ||||
| 1993 | Beth Green, WIT | Cynthia Holliday, WIT | ||
| 1992 | Beth Green, WIT | Cynthia Holliday, WIT | ||
| 1991 | Molly Dietz, ALL | Sara Lee, DEN | ||
| 1990 | Molly Dietz, ALL | Bridget Sheehan, ALL | ||
| 1989 | Molly Dietz, ALL | Pat Milkovich, OBE | ||
| 1988 | Holly Swank, KEN | Cynthia Krzystofiak, DEN | ||
| 1987 | Holly Swank, KEN | Bridget Sheehan, ALL | ||
| Carol Frederick, ALL | ||||
| 1986 | Gwen Herron, ALL | Mary Parker, OWU | ||
| Gretchen Weitbrecht, KEN | ||||
| 1985 | Karen Light, WOO | Gretchen Weitbrecht, KEN | ||
| 1984 | Debbie Stockham, WOO |