Softball
| Player of the Year |
Pitcher of the Year |
Coach of the Year | Newcomer of the Year | |
| 2013 | Jamie Samuel, KEN | Emily Bichler, DPU | Erica Hanrahan, DPU | Loren Combs, WIT |
| 2012 | Stephanie Fort, ALL | Caitlin Nealer, ALL | Sandra Sanford, ALL | Demi Hart, WOO |
| 2011 | Erica Evans, DEN | Rebecca Dyer, DEN | Cassie Cunningham, OWU | Jen Anderson, OWU |
| 2010 | Whitney Dropsey, HIR | Rachel Seibel, WIT | Tiffany Ozbun, DEN | Jamie Samuel, KEN |
| 2009 | Whitney Dropsey, HIR | Rachael Hatcher, WIT | Tiffany Ozbun, DEN | Bessie Artino, ALL |
| 2008 | Abby Bodenlos, ALL | Rachel Seibel, WOU | Cassie Cunningham, OWU | Marci Potuzko, ALL |
| 2007 | Abby Bodenlos, ALL | Rachel Thomas, DEN | Kristin Tassey, HIR | Cameron Catalfu, WIT |
| 2006 | Sarah Downs, OWU | Giannina Coccaro, ALL | Holly Bruder, DEN |
Erin Porter, DEN Rachel Ryan, ALL |
| 2005 | Stephanie Zorn, WIT |
Natalie Barone, WOO Claire Martin, WOO |
Sandra Sanford, ALL Lori Schimmel, WOO |
Claire Kopko, DEN |
| 2004 | Carmen Montgomery, WIT | Giannina Coccaro, ALL | JoAnne Ferguson, KEN | Ashley Morrison, KEN |
| 2003 | Beth Walters, WIT | Emily Thornton, OWU | Becky Hall, WIT | Amy Mazur, OWU |
| 2002 | Erika Downs, ALL | Courtney Zollars, DEN | Renee Hicks, ALL | Norah Gillam, WIT |
| 2001 | Courtney Zollars, DEN | Courtney Zollars, DEN | Wendy Figgins, DEN | Angie Barone, WOO |
| 2000 | Courtney Zollars, DEN | Carey Oakes, WIT | Becky Hall, WIT | Alea Bruggeman, WIT |
| 1999 | Jen Lorenzen, ALL | Robin Shesky, DEN | Wendy Figgins, DEN | |
| 1998 | Laura Fromm, ALL | Becky Palmer, CWR | Karen Chambers, CWRU |