Football
| Offensive Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Coach of the Year | Newcomer of the Year | |
| 2011 | Ben Zoeller, WIT | C.J. Gum, WAB | Erik Raeburn, WAB | A.J. Akinribade, WAB |
| 2010 | Ben Zoeller, WIT | C.J. Gum, WAB | Joe Fincham, WIT | Richard Barnes, WOO |
| 2009 | Matt Hudson, WAB | Eddie Vallery, WIT | Joe Fincham, WIT | James Huddleston, OWU |
| 2008 | Matt Hudson, WAB | Darryl Kennon, WAB | Mike Schmitz, WOO | John Hull, HIR |
| 2007 | R.V. Carroll, OBE | Adrian Pynenberg, WAB | Chris Creighton, WAB | Brad McKinley, WIT |
| 2006 | Tristan Murray, WIT | Adrian Pynenberg, WAB | Joe Fincham, WIT | Aaron Huffman, WIT |
| 2005 | Russ Harbaugh, WAB | Cisco Clervoix, OWU | Chris Creighton, WAB | Dustin Sheppard, WOO |
| 2004 | Tony Sutton, WOO | Joe Kearney, WOO | Mike Schmitz, WOO | Tristan Murray, WIT |
| 2003 | Tony Sutton, WOO | Blair Hammer, WAB | Mark Matlak, ALL | Aaron Lafitte,WAB |
| 2002 | Jake Knot, WAB | Nate Boulais, WAB | Chris Creighton, WAB | Tony Sutton, WOO |
| 2001 | Jake Knot, WAB | Juan Howard, WIT | Joe Fincham, WIT | Ricky Valenzuela, OBE |
| 2000 | Casey Donaldson, WIT | Seth Duerr, WOO | Joe Fincham, WIT | Sam Hobi, OBE |
| 1999 | Casey Donaldson, WIT | Seth Duerr, WOO | Joe Fincham, WIT | Elio Harmon, WIT |
| 1998 | Casey Donaldson, WIT | Ken Pope, WIT | Joe Fincham, WIT | Dustin Goldsbury, WIT |
| 1997 | Jim Mormino, ALL | Kent Rafey, WIT | Jim Barnes, WOO | Casey Donaldson, WIT |
| 1996 | Marcus Booke, WIT | Nick Reiser, ALL | Ken O’Keefe, ALL | Brock Wanless, WOO |
| 1995 | Marcus Booke, WIT | Tim Altman, WIT | Doug Neibuhr, WIT | Ken Pope, WIT |
| 1994 | Paul Bell, ALL | Mike Sanders, WIT | Frank Carr, ERL | |
| 1993 | Marlon Perryman, WIT | Taver Johnson, WIT | Ken O'Keefe, ALL | |
| Rich Zdrojewski, CWRU | ||||
| 1992 | Stanley Drayton, ALL | Taver Johnson, WIT | Doug Neibuhr, WIT | |
| 1991 | Brian Grandison, WOO | Keith Rucker, OWU | Ken O'Keefe, ALL | |
| 1990 | Jon Warga, WIT | Neil Ringers, OWU | Ken O'Keefe, ALL | |
| 1989 | Chris Creighton, KEN | Neil Ringers, OWU | Mike Hollway, OWU | |
| Jim Meyer, KEN | ||||
| 1988 | Paul Washlock, CWRU | Mike Parker, ALL | Peter Vaas, ALL | |
| 1987 | Eric Dahlquist, KEN | Mike Parker, ALL | Peter Vaas, ALL | |
| 1986 | Chris Spriggs, DEN | Dan Holland, DEN | Keith Piper, DEN | |
| 1985 | Chris Spriggs, DEN | Jay Todd, CWRU | Keith Piper, DEN | |
| 1984 | Fred DiSanto, CWRU | Bob Nau, OBE | Jim Chapman, CWRU | |